Breaking into the payer ecosystem represents one of the most challenging yet lucrative opportunities in digital health. With Medicare Advantage payments increasing by 3.70% or over $16 billion from 2024 to 2025, and only seven MA plans earning 5-star ratings in 2025 down from 38 in 2024 as CMS raised quality performance thresholds, health plans are under unprecedented pressure to demonstrate value while controlling costs. This creates a critical window for digital health solutions that can prove measurable impact on quality metrics and member outcomes.
For pharmaceutical and biotech marketing executives, understanding what moves the needle for payers isn’t just about product features—it’s about demonstrating alignment with the complex regulatory, financial, and operational realities that drive payer decision-making. The stakes couldn’t be higher: successful payer partnerships can scale digital health solutions to millions of members, while missteps can lock companies out of lucrative markets for years.
While Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans cover all 21 digital medicine services explored in recent research, private health plans in Medicare Advantage programs do not offer the same comprehensive coverage, creating both challenges and opportunities for digital health partners who understand the nuanced landscape of payer priorities.
Understanding the Payer Landscape: What’s Driving Decision-Making in 2025
The Star Rating Imperative for Medicare Advantage Plans
The dramatic reduction in 5-star Medicare Advantage plans signals a fundamental shift in how CMS evaluates plan performance. With Star Ratings plummeting and CMS raising quality performance thresholds, elite plans are leveraging specific health IT strategies to drive quality outcomes that directly impact their bonus payments and market competitiveness.
For digital health partners, this creates clear positioning opportunities around solutions that demonstrably improve Healthcare Effectiveness Data and Information Set (HEDIS) measures, Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (CAHPS) scores, and clinical quality metrics that feed into Star Ratings calculations.
Commercial Payer Focus on Payment Integrity and Risk Management
Health plans are innovating payment integrity while minimizing risk, driven by the need to balance member satisfaction with cost containment in an increasingly competitive marketplace. Commercial payers are particularly focused on digital health solutions that provide clear return on investment through reduced medical costs, improved care coordination, and enhanced member engagement.
Regulatory Modernization Creates New Partnership Pathways
CMS is taking bold steps to modernize the nation’s digital health ecosystem with a focus on empowering Medicare beneficiaries through greater access to innovative health technologies, in partnership with the Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology. This regulatory evolution creates new pathways for digital health partnerships while establishing clearer frameworks for evaluation and implementation.
The Payer Evaluation Framework: Five Critical Assessment Areas
1. Clinical Evidence and Outcomes Validation
Payers demand robust clinical evidence that demonstrates measurable improvements in member health outcomes. Digital health interventions have enormous potential as scalable tools to improve health and healthcare delivery by improving effectiveness, efficiency, accessibility, safety and personalization, but payers require proof of these improvements through rigorous evaluation methodologies.
Key evidence requirements include:
- Peer-reviewed published studies demonstrating clinical efficacy
- Real-world evidence from comparable member populations
- Statistical significance in relevant health outcome measures
- Cost-effectiveness analyses with clear ROI projections
- Integration with existing quality measurement frameworks
2. Regulatory Compliance and Data Security
HIPAA compliance remains non-negotiable for payer partnerships, with specific requirements for protected health information handling and disclosure protocols. Payers evaluate digital health partners’ compliance infrastructure as a prerequisite for any partnership discussion.
Compliance evaluation criteria:
- HIPAA Security Rule implementation and documentation
- Business Associate Agreement readiness and terms
- Data breach prevention and response protocols
- Audit trail capabilities for member data access
- Interoperability standards compliance including FHIR and HL7
3. Technical Integration and Interoperability
Payers are increasingly focused on advancing interoperability and improving prior authorization processes, making seamless technical integration a critical partnership requirement. Digital health solutions must demonstrate the ability to integrate with existing payer systems without disrupting established workflows.
Technical assessment areas:
- Electronic health record integration capabilities
- Claims processing system compatibility
- Prior authorization workflow optimization
- Member portal and communication system integration
- Real-time data exchange and reporting functionality
4. Financial Model Alignment and Risk Sharing
CMS’s goal in new models like States Advancing AHEAD is to collaborate with states to curb health care cost growth, improve population health, and promote healthier living. This trend toward value-based contracting extends to payer partnerships with digital health companies.
Financial evaluation focuses on:
- Outcome-based pricing models and risk-sharing arrangements
- Total cost of care impact analysis
- Member acquisition and retention cost improvements
- Administrative burden reduction and operational efficiency gains
- Scalability economics across different member populations
5. Member Experience and Engagement Metrics
Payers increasingly recognize that member satisfaction directly impacts retention, Star Ratings, and overall plan performance. Digital health partners must demonstrate superior member experience design and proven engagement outcomes.
Member experience evaluation criteria:
- User interface design and accessibility compliance
- Member onboarding and activation success rates
- Sustained engagement metrics and retention analytics
- Customer support integration and response capabilities
- Multi-language and culturally competent design features
Strategic Positioning for Payer Partnership Success
Align Solution Messaging with Payer Priorities
Payers have been relatively slow to adopt digital and AI tools, but a purposeful approach to healthcare payer digital transformation could create meaningful value. This presents opportunities for digital health companies that can clearly articulate how their solutions address specific payer pain points rather than generic technology benefits.
Effective messaging strategies:
- Lead with member outcome improvements and quality measure impacts
- Quantify cost savings through reduced utilization or care coordination efficiency
- Demonstrate integration capabilities that minimize implementation burden
- Highlight regulatory compliance leadership and risk mitigation benefits
- Provide case studies from comparable payer partnerships with measurable results
Develop Payer-Specific Value Propositions
Medicare Advantage plans, commercial insurers, and Medicaid managed care organizations have distinct priorities that require tailored value propositions. Understanding these differences enables more effective partnership positioning.
For Medicare Advantage Plans:
- Focus on Star Rating improvement through specific HEDIS measure enhancement
- Emphasize chronic care management and medication adherence solutions
- Highlight member satisfaction improvements and CAHPS score optimization
- Demonstrate integration with Medicare compliance requirements
For Commercial Payers:
- Emphasize employer group satisfaction and employee health outcomes
- Focus on preventive care engagement and early intervention capabilities
- Highlight workforce productivity improvements and absenteeism reduction
- Demonstrate premium cost management through medical cost reduction
For Medicaid Managed Care:
- Focus on health equity improvements and social determinants of health
- Emphasize care coordination for complex, high-need populations
- Highlight community health improvement and population health management
- Demonstrate cultural competency and accessibility for diverse populations
Implementation Strategies: Building Successful Payer Partnerships
Establish Pilot Program Frameworks
Payers prefer low-risk partnership approaches that allow for measurement and optimization before full-scale implementation. Successful digital health companies structure pilot programs that provide clear success metrics while minimizing payer investment and operational disruption.
Pilot program elements:
- Limited member population with defined inclusion criteria
- Specific, measurable outcomes tied to payer priorities
- Defined timeline with milestone checkpoints and success criteria
- Clear pathway to scale based on pilot results
- Risk-sharing arrangements that align partner incentives
Develop Comprehensive Data and Analytics Capabilities
Expert evaluation of digital health products requires sophisticated assessment approaches including quantitative agreement measurement using terciles of responses, medians, and distribution of appropriateness scores. Payers expect robust analytics and reporting capabilities that enable continuous monitoring and optimization.
Analytics requirements:
- Real-time dashboards showing member engagement and clinical outcomes
- Integration with payer quality measurement and reporting systems
- Predictive analytics for member risk stratification and intervention targeting
- Cost-effectiveness tracking and ROI calculation capabilities
- Compliance monitoring and audit reporting functionality
Build Strategic Advisory Relationships
Successful payer partnerships often begin with advisory relationships that provide insights into payer priorities while demonstrating digital health company expertise. These relationships can evolve into formal partnerships when mutual value is clearly established.
Advisory relationship strategies:
- Participate in payer innovation challenges and pilot programs
- Contribute to industry conferences and thought leadership initiatives
- Provide expertise on regulatory developments and best practices
- Collaborate on research studies and outcome measurement initiatives
- Engage in policy discussions and advocacy efforts
Overcoming Common Partnership Obstacles
Addressing Implementation Timeline Concerns
Payers often hesitate to engage with digital health partners due to concerns about implementation complexity and timeline disruption. Successful companies address these concerns proactively through proven implementation methodologies and change management expertise.
Implementation acceleration strategies:
- Develop standardized integration protocols and technical specifications
- Provide dedicated implementation teams with payer experience
- Create comprehensive training and support programs for payer staff
- Establish clear communication protocols and project management frameworks
- Offer phased implementation approaches that minimize operational disruption
Managing Regulatory and Compliance Complexity
Digital Technology Assessment Criteria include requirements covering clinical safety, data protection, technical security, interoperability, plus usability and accessibility, with products needing to meet all requirements in each area. Navigating this complexity requires sophisticated compliance management and regulatory expertise.
Compliance management strategies:
- Maintain current regulatory expertise and legal counsel specializing in healthcare
- Develop comprehensive compliance documentation and audit capabilities
- Establish ongoing monitoring and updating processes for regulatory changes
- Create standardized Business Associate Agreements and contract templates
- Provide regular compliance training and certification for all team members
Demonstrating Scalability and Sustainability
Payers require confidence that digital health partners can scale solutions across large member populations while maintaining quality and effectiveness. This requires demonstrating both technical scalability and organizational capability.
Scalability demonstration methods:
- Provide case studies showing successful scaling across multiple payer partnerships
- Document technical infrastructure capabilities and redundancy measures
- Demonstrate financial stability and long-term viability as a partner
- Show organizational growth capabilities and talent acquisition strategies
- Provide references from existing payer partners regarding partnership satisfaction
Future-Proofing Payer Partnership Strategies
Anticipating Value-Based Care Evolution
The healthcare industry’s continued evolution toward value-based care models creates opportunities for digital health partners that can demonstrate clear value alignment with quality outcomes and cost management objectives.
Value-based positioning strategies:
- Develop outcomes-based contracting capabilities and risk-sharing models
- Create integrated solutions that span the care continuum
- Build population health management and risk stratification capabilities
- Establish partnerships with provider organizations and health systems
- Demonstrate expertise in quality measure improvement and reporting
Preparing for Regulatory Technology Advancement
Digital therapeutics and software-based in vitro diagnostics represent innovative solutions that use meaningful data to provide evidence-based decisions for disease prevention, treatment, and management, requiring sophisticated regulatory navigation and reimbursement pathway development.
Regulatory preparation strategies:
- Stay current with FDA digital therapeutics regulatory pathways
- Develop health technology assessment and health economics capabilities
- Build relationships with payer medical directors and clinical leadership
- Participate in industry initiatives and regulatory working groups
- Invest in evidence generation and real-world evidence capabilities
Taking Action: Your Roadmap to Payer Partnership Success
The payer partnership landscape presents both unprecedented opportunities and significant challenges for digital health companies. Success requires understanding the complex interplay of regulatory requirements, financial pressures, and operational realities that drive payer decision-making.
The companies that will dominate payer partnerships are those that can demonstrate clear value alignment with payer priorities while navigating the sophisticated evaluation processes that health plans use to assess digital health partners. This requires moving beyond generic technology pitches toward evidence-based value propositions that address specific payer pain points and opportunities.
Your path to payer partnership success begins with understanding what payers actually need to say yes. The frameworks and strategies outlined here provide the foundation for building partnerships that create sustainable competitive advantages while delivering measurable value to health plan members and operations.
The window for establishing payer partnerships has never been more favorable, with regulatory modernization, quality pressure, and member experience demands creating clear opportunities for digital health solutions that can demonstrate real-world impact. The key is positioning your solution not just as a technology innovation, but as a strategic partner in payers’ efforts to improve member outcomes while managing costs effectively.
Ready to accelerate your payer partnership strategy? Book a discovery call with our healthcare partnership experts to develop a customized approach that addresses payer priorities while positioning your digital health solution for sustainable competitive advantage. Our proven methodologies have helped leading digital health companies successfully navigate payer partnerships and achieve scale across Medicare Advantage, commercial, and Medicaid markets.
Sources and References
- American Medical Association. (2025). AMA sheds light on commercial payer coverage for digital medicine. https://www.ama-assn.org/press-center/press-releases/ama-sheds-light-commercial-payer-coverage-digital-medicine
- McKinsey & Company. (2024). The future of Medicare Advantage. https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/healthcare/our-insights/the-future-of-medicare-advantage
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. (2025). CMS Seeks Public Input on Improving Technology to Empower Medicare Beneficiaries. https://www.cms.gov/newsroom/press-releases/cms-seeks-public-input-improving-technology-empower-medicare-beneficiaries
- ClarisHealth. (2025). Maximizing Opportunity with 2025 Healthcare Payer Technology Trends. https://www.clarishealth.com/blog/healthcare-payer-technology-trends/
- McKinsey & Company. (2025). A guide to healthcare payer digital transformation. https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/healthcare/our-insights/rewiring-healthcare-payers-a-guide-to-digital-and-ai-transformation
- Black Book Research. (2025). The Digital Playbook Behind 2025’s Top Medicare Advantage and Commercial Health Plans. https://www.pharmiweb.com/press-release/2025-06-01/black-book-research-reveals-the-digital-playbook-behind-2025s-top-medicare-advantage-and-commercial
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. (2025). 2025 Medicare Advantage and Part D Rate Announcement. https://www.cms.gov/newsroom/fact-sheets/2025-medicare-advantage-and-part-d-rate-announcement
- PMC Digital Health Research. Evaluating digital health interventions: key questions and approaches. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5324832/
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2025). Summary of the HIPAA Privacy Rule. https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/laws-regulations/index.html
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2013). Guidance: Treatment, Payment, and Health Care Operations. https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/guidance/disclosures-treatment-payment-health-care-operations/index.html
- PMC Health Economics Research. Access and reimbursement pathways for digital health solutions and in vitro diagnostic devices. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9986593/
- ORCHA Health. (2023). Digital Technology Assessment Criteria. https://orchahealth.com/our-products/assessment-frameworks/digital-technology-assessment-criteria-dtac/
- PMC Health Policy Research. Considerations for US coverage and reimbursement: Which digital health products to evaluate? https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11293764/
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. (2023). States Advancing All-Payer Health Equity Approaches and Development (AHEAD) Model. https://www.cms.gov/priorities/innovation/innovation-models/ahead
- Federal Register. (2024). Medicare and Medicaid Programs; Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act; Advancing Interoperability and Improving Prior Authorization Processes. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2024/02/08/2024-00895/medicare-and-medicaid-programs-patient-protection-and-affordable-care-act-advancing-interoperability
